• Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • FOCUS 2021
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • My Column
Friday, February 26, 2021
MediaNews4U
  • Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • FOCUS 2021
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
        • Market Analysis
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • My Column
No Result
View All Result
MediaNews4U
  • Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • FOCUS 2021
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
        • Market Analysis
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • My Column
No Result
View All Result
MediaNews4U.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Exclusive

KBC Har Seat Hot Seat Contest: Star India and Airtel gets reprieve from SC in unfair trade practices case

by Editorial
February 22, 2020
in Exclusive, Featured
3 min read
KBC Har Seat Hot Seat Contest: Star India and Airtel gets reprieve from SC in unfair trade practices case
Share Share ShareShare

New Delhi: The Supreme Court of India has overturned a verdict of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in which it had found Star India and Airtel guilty of indulging in unfair trade practices during the broadcast of Star India’s programme Kaun Banega Crorepati (KBC) in 2007.

In the case filed by a consumer society named the ‘Society of Catalysts’, the Commission was of the view that the program’s ‘Har Seat Hot Seat’ contest amounted to an unfair trade practice.

Through KBC’s ‘Har Seat Hot Seat’ contest invited viewers of the program to participate in an objective-type question contest, where the viewer was required to select out of four possible answers and send his answer in through SMS services offered by Airtel. A winner for each episode was then selected randomly out of those who sent in the correct answers and a prize of Rs. 2 lakhs was awarded to the winner. Though there was no entry fee for HSHS, a participant was required to pay Rs. 2.40 per SMS to Airtel – substantially higher than the normal SMS rate. The main allegations leveled against KBC’s ‘Har Seat Hot Seat’ contest were that it created a false impression in viewers’ minds that participation was free of cost, though the cost of organizing the contest as well as the prize money was reimbursed from the increased rate of SMS charges, and that profits from these charges were being shared by Airtel and Star India.

Consequentially, the NCDR Commission held that Star India had committed an unfair trade practice, as the prize money for HSHS was fully or partly covered by the revenue generated from the unjustifiably high SMS costs. Punitive damages of Rs. 1 crore were thus awarded against Star India and Airtel by the Commission

Subsequently, Star India had appealed to the Supreme Court where it contended that the Commission’s decision was based merely on inferences, speculation, and reliance on an uncorroborated newspaper report. It was also argued that there was no revenue sharing agreement between Star India and Airtel and that the only monetary flow between them was a periodic fixed lump-sum to be paid by Airtel under the services-cum-sponsorship agreement between the two parties. Furthermore, the imposition of a higher SMS rate was claimed to be justified on the basis that the transmission of SMSes to register options in a multiple-choice question game required special software and that this constituted a value-added service. Additionally, since Star India had conformed with relevant TRAI regulations mandating that increased tariff (for SMSes) be displayed on the television screen, no question of duping the participants arose; participants were thus duly informed of the increased SMS cost, while participation in the HSHS contest itself remained free of charge.

Subsequently, The Supreme court dismissed the Commission’s holding that the HSHS prize money was distributed out of the contest’s SMS revenue as baseless and unsupported. Further SC verdict observed that Airtel was merely a sponsor/advertiser and that the commercial agreement between Star India and Airtel dictated that Airtel would pay sponsorship charges while Star India would be independently liable for paying the prize money out of its own pocket irrespective of the revenue earned by Airtel.

The court further discredited the Commission’s reliance on the aforementioned Hindustan Times news report, insofar as the same was uncorroborated and not even produced before either the Commission or the court. Thus, in the court’s eyes, the complainant failed “to establish any direct linkage between the increased SMS tariff rates and prize money so as to show that the prize money was deceptively recovered in the guise of increased SMS rates charged to participants.”

Looking at the increased costs of SMSes for participation in the HSHS contest, the court found that the same constituted a value-added service as Airtel had to set up the hardware and software required for a contest of this format at its own cost. This was reinforced by the TRAI’s direction on ‘Premium Rate Services’ (dated 03.05.2005) issued by TRAI, in which it is categorically stated that televoting and participating in quizzes, etc. through SMS constitute a value-added service. Thus, the court dismissed the complainant’s argument that the appellants had wrongfully imposed additional SMS costs or wrongfully advertised the same as well.

The court, therefore, found that the Commission’s finding of an unfair trade practice was bad in law and accordingly it allowed the appeals and set the impugned judgment aside.

Tags: Kaun Banega Crorepati 2007KBC Har Seat Hot Seat Contest

Related Posts

Unemployment emerges as India’s biggest worry, pushes COVID19 to 2nd spot in February: Ipsos survey
Featured

Unemployment emerges as India’s biggest worry, pushes COVID19 to 2nd spot in February: Ipsos survey

by Editorial
February 25, 2021
0

New Delhi: According to the February wave of the Ipsos What Worries the World global survey, Unemployment has emerged as...

Read more
Nielsen rolls out id resolution system for global attribution measurement
Advertising

Nielsen rolls out id resolution system for global attribution measurement

by Editorial
February 25, 2021
0

Mumbai: Nielsen (NLSN) today announced a new approach that moves away from third-party cookies to privacy-centric, people-based identifiers for Attribution....

Read more
TAM AdEx: Ad Volumes of Retail sector on Television plunged by 35% in Y 2020 over Y 2018

TAM AdEx: Life Insurance Ad Volumes in Print witnesses 34% growth

February 25, 2021
ASCI guidelines boon or bane for Influencers?

ASCI guidelines for Influencers; boon or bane ?

February 24, 2021
Vishwanath Shetty, Pocket Aces

Branded content at Pocket Aces have observed a 50% year-on-year revenue growth: Vishwanath Shetty, Pocket Aces

February 24, 2021
Shahir Muneer, Founder and Director,Divo

Influencer marketing is here and well to stay, with the number of brands and adoption to it increasing day by day: Shahir Muneer

February 24, 2021
We firmly believe that alone we can do little but together we can do a lot: Ankur Gupta, Golden Shine Trust

We firmly believe that alone we can do little but together we can do a lot: Ankur Gupta, Golden Shine Trust

February 24, 2021
ASCI’s mandate is to look at advertising content and make sure that it is honest and non-offensive, and fair: Manisha Kapoor, ASCI

ASCI’s mandate is to look at advertising content and make sure that it is honest and non-offensive, and fair: Manisha Kapoor, ASCI

February 23, 2021

Subscribe to Newsletters

Trending

MX Player ropes in Sidd Mantri as Senior VP, Product
Featured

MX Player ropes in Sidd Mantri as Senior VP, Product

by Editorial
February 25, 2021
0

Mumbai: MX Player has roped in product expert/ leader Sidd (Siddharth) Mantri as Senior VP - Product, who is responsible...

COTT Week 7: Live Telecast was the top show with 47.42 Million unique viewership.

COTT Week 7: Live Telecast was the top show with 47.42 Million unique viewers

February 25, 2021
India will account for 76% of the Disney+ base in APAC and 40% of revenues this year: MPA

India will account for 76% of the Disney+ base in APAC and 40% of revenues this year: MPA

February 25, 2021
Ruchika Varma, Chief Marketing Officer, Future Generali India Insurance

We are a brand that leads with empathy and genuinely addresses customer needs: Ruchika Varma

February 25, 2021
Asianet to telecast a new serial “Santhwanam“ from 21st September

Asianet to telecast a new serial “Santhwanam“ from 21st September

September 19, 2020

Contact Us :

UPLIFT MEDIANEWS4U DIGITAL PVT LTD

No. 82, Aram Nagar 2, JP Road

Versova, Andheri West

Mumbai – 400061

Umanath.V
+91-99400-17868
umanath@medianews4u.com

© 2019 medianews4u.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • FOCUS 2021
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • My Column

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.