Tuesday, May 13, 2025
MediaNews4U
  • Exclusive
  • Advertising
  • Media
    • Radio
    • Cable & DTH
    • Print
    • Digital Frontier
    • Gaming Nexus
  • Television
  • OTT
  • Ad-Tech
  • Marketing
  • Campaigns
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Think Through
    • Prescience 2023
    • Prescience 2024
  • People
  • Events
    • Leader Speak
    • STRAIGHT TALK
    • Gamechangers
    • Print & TV Summit
MediaNews4U
  • Exclusive
  • Advertising
  • Media
    • Radio
    • Cable & DTH
    • Print
    • Digital Frontier
    • Gaming Nexus
  • Television
  • OTT
  • Ad-Tech
  • Marketing
  • Campaigns
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Think Through
    • Prescience 2023
    • Prescience 2024
  • People
  • Events
    • Leader Speak
    • STRAIGHT TALK
    • Gamechangers
    • Print & TV Summit
MediaNews4U.com
Home Featured

Will Amul controversy dent brand’s equity in Karnataka?

With elections around the corner, agenda is politically driven, say market watchers. Amul cheese and butter too entrenched to take a hit, they reason.

by Neethu Mohan
April 11, 2023
in Featured, Exclusive
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
Will Amul controversy dent brand’s equity in Karnataka?
Share Share ShareShare

A social media post from dairy giant Amul on its foray into the milk and curd category in poll-bound Karnataka via e-commerce channels has landed the brand in controversy. 

ADVERTISEMENT

A section of people from Karnataka have expressed their angst and concern over the adverse effect Amul’s entry will have on homegrown dairy brand Nandini from the Karnataka Milk Federation (KMF). For the past few days hashtags like #SaveNandini #GoBackAmul #BoycottAmul were also doing rounds on Twitter. 

Opposition parties have alleged that the current government is intending to kill the local cooperative sector by not blocking Amul’s entry. They also added that Amul’s entry will lead to an unhealthy competition which in the long run will destroy the cooperative systems. 

A new wave of freshness with milk and curd is coming
to Bengaluru. More information coming soon. #LaunchAlert pic.twitter.com/q2SCGsmsFP

— Amul.coop (@Amul_Coop) April 5, 2023

All sorts of opinions including the politically driven have been doing the rounds. Comparisons on price have also been made, before it was announced that Amul is not entering Karnataka (for fresh dairy products). 

450ml ge 29, nandini 500ml ge 23.
Nandini samrudhi(purple packet) gatti haalu 500ml 24.
Priya kannada naadina janare neeve yoochisi…. pic.twitter.com/YQ6hBifHbj

— I'm a Student (@CHIRAGR12710734) April 7, 2023

Nandini’s premium milk product is sold at Rs 44 per litre and Amul’s at Rs 54. Amul’s pouched curd is priced at Rs 66 per kg and Nandini at Rs 46.  

In an interview with Deccan Herald, Jayen Mehta, MD, clarified saying that the objective of the social media posts was to inform that soon people of Bengaluru would be able to buy fresh Amul milk and curd through e-commerce platforms. The brand has also been receiving a lot of enquiries for the products, hence Amul’s milk and curd will be available online. He had added that any manufacturer can sell products anywhere in India as the country is an open market and such a sale cannot be opposed. This was of course before it was announced that Amul will not make the foray.

Industry watchers believe that it is a politically driven controversy with an intention to grab headlines stoking Kannadiga pride ahead the upcoming state assembly polls. 

We posed the question: Will Amul’s push in fresh dairy dent brand’s equity in Karnataka?

Lloyd Mathias
Lloyd Mathias

Lloyd Mathias, Business Strategist and former marketing head of HP Asia, said, “I don’t think so. Milk as a product is very unique. Amul is a national player which is based in Gujarat. Similarly, there are several milk cooperative federations in different states. Karnataka has Nandini, Haryana has Vita, and each of them have their competence in specific geographies. Nandini is very well entrenched in Karnataka. Secondly, as I understand Amul has only entered the packaged milk category. The real challenge will come when they enter the fresh milk category, which I believe is not in their plans right now. The products they have launched will only go through e-commerce and quick-commerce channels.”

Ramanujam Sridhar

Ramanujam Sridhar, Founder CEO, Integrated Brand.Comm and author, thinks that the whole Amul vs Nandini controversy is engineered as the legislative assembly elections are round the corner. 

“Everybody is looking for the headline space. If the entry of Nestle is allowed, why can’t Amul enter the Karnataka market?” asks Sridhar. 

He added, “As a consumer the more choices I get, it is better for me. I have been living in Bangalore for the last 42 years and every house will have a Nandini milk packet at their doorsteps in the morning. They have successful products with a successful distribution network. Every street corner will have a Nandini outlet. In fact, other brands like Hatsun and Heritage are available in Karnataka. I don’t know why a well-entrenched brand like Nandini should feel threatened with the entry of another brand. Amul is the pioneer of the cooperative dairy movement in the country. I believe people who are talking are not aware of the history and the controversy will die down once the election is over.”

Ramesh Narayan
Ramesh Narayan

Ramesh Narayan, Founder, Canco Advertising, also believes that the controversy is a political fight and has nothing to do with the market realities. 

“Karnataka Milk Federation has been operating under the classic co-operative model in Karnataka since the mid-seventies. Its fresh milk is hugely cheaper than the milk Amul sells in Gujarat or Delhi. The consumer isn’t a moron. In this case she is actually your wife. I am confident that consumers in Karnataka will make a considered choice based on ease of availability, price and quality. My impression is that the Nandini brand scores well on all these three points. Given the fact that we have a free market for every other product, why are certain people so scared that Karnataka users will shift en masse to Amul without a proper reason to do so? The only reason for this political hysteria could be that certain politicians feel that if the electorate was so naive as to vote for them, they might be equally foolish in their purchase decisions. Personally, I am confident that this is a purely political fight. It has nothing to do with market realities,” he said. 

Whatever the reason, will it hit sales of Amul butter and cheese in Karnataka? 

Sridhar said, “Amul is a well-entrenched brand. Their butter and cheese products are popular and I don’t see Nandini equivalent to that. At the end, these are all Indian products and these sorts of differences are man-made. Ultimately, the consumers will be the driving force.”

Mathias added, “The polls are around the corner and its unavoidable politics. There will be a little bit of hue and cry the politicians will make, which will not have any impact. Amul cheese and butter are well-established products with high brand equity.”

Tags: #BoycottAmul#GoBackAmul#SaveNandiniAmulbrand-commDeccan HeraldJayen MehtaKarnatakaKarnataka electionsKarnataka legislative electionsKarnataka Milk FederationLloyd MathiasNandiniRamanujam SridharRamesh Narayanan

RECENT POSTS

The future of marketing relies on blending hyper-personalisation, immersive experiences, and predictive intelligence: Swati Bhargava, CashKaro
Exclusive

The future of marketing relies on blending hyper-personalisation, immersive experiences, and predictive intelligence: Swati Bhargava, CashKaro

May 13, 2025
0

CashKaro, a cashback platform, recently unveiled India’s first-ever Ghibli-style advertisement, delivering a message about the inefficacy of coin-based cashback. The...

Read more
Inclusive AI for Bharat: Marketing Leaders Chart the Future of Rural Engagement Through Purposeful Tech
Exclusive

Inclusive AI for Bharat: Marketing Leaders Chart the Future of Rural Engagement Through Purposeful Tech

May 12, 2025
0

At the MMA Impact India event, a high-stakes conversation unfolded on the future of Artificial Intelligence in rural India. Titled...

Read more
Brands celebrate the many facets of Motherhood: Mother's Day 2025
Exclusive

Brands celebrate the many facets of Motherhood: Mother’s Day 2025

May 12, 2025
0

This Mother’s Day, brands across sectors launched heartfelt campaigns celebrating the strength, love, and evolving roles of mothers. From highlighting...

Read more
Digital Maturity is the New Growth Engine – Insights from India Inc.’s Marketing Vanguard
Exclusive

Digital Maturity is the New Growth Engine – Insights from India Inc.’s Marketing Vanguard

May 12, 2025
0

As Indian enterprises navigate an era of rapid digital disruption, the question is no longer if brands should transform, but...

Read more
We brainstormed ways to link cricket, farming, and protection to embody Kshema’s values of trust, reliability, and protection: Bhaskar Thakur
Exclusive

We merged cricket, farming, and protection to reflect Kshema’s trust and reliability: Bhaskar Thakur

May 12, 2025
0

Kshema General Insurance the 'Official General Insurance Partner' of IPL team Punjab Kings is doing a 'Kshema Secure Hands' digital...

Read more
Brand Campaigns That Celebrate Every Shade of Motherhood: Mother's Day 2025
Exclusive

Brand Campaigns That Celebrate Every Shade of Motherhood: Mother’s Day 2025

May 10, 2025
0

Mumbai: This Mother’s Day, brands across India have gone beyond flowers and gifts, crafting powerful campaigns that honor the many...

Read more

LATEST NEWS

Abhishek Mehrotra Quits News24, joins AATHARVI Production Multimedia as President

Abhishek Mehrotra Quits News24, joins AATHARVI Production Multimedia as President

May 13, 2025
CNN elevates Ellana Lee to Global senior role, expands focus on Sponsored Content

CNN elevates Ellana Lee to Global senior role, expands focus on Sponsored Content

May 12, 2025

ANALYSIS

There’s a growing opportunity for Salman Khan to transition into more mature, character-driven roles that align with his age and legacy: Ormax Media
Analysis

There’s a growing opportunity for Salman Khan to transition into more mature, character-driven roles that align with his age and legacy: Ormax Media

May 9, 2025
0

MUMBAI: There’s a growing opportunity for Salman Khan to transition into more mature, character-driven roles that align with his age...

PEOPLE

Abhishek Mehrotra Quits News24, joins AATHARVI Production Multimedia as President
People

Abhishek Mehrotra Quits News24, joins AATHARVI Production Multimedia as President

May 13, 2025
0

Mumbai: Sr. Journalist Abhishek Mehrotra has joined AATHARVI Production Multimedia Pvt Ltd as President. In his new role Mehrotra will...

MARKETING

Nikita Saxena named Head of Digital Marketing at JSW Steel
Marketing

Nikita Saxena named Head of Digital Marketing at JSW Steel

May 12, 2025
0

Mumbai: Nikita Saxena has been appointed as Head of Digital Marketing at JSW Steel. Saxena shared news of her new...

Subscribe to Newsletters

ADVERTISING

EssenceMediacom wins Consolidated Media Mandate for Hero MotoCorp
Advertising

EssenceMediacom wins Consolidated Media Mandate for Hero MotoCorp

May 12, 2025
0

Mumbai: EssenceMediacom, GroupM’s flagship media agency, has won the prestigious consolidated media mandate for Hero MotoCorp, the world’s largest manufacturer...

PRINT

Veteran Journalist Vinay Kamath Bids Farewell to BusinessLine After 27 Years
People

Veteran Journalist Vinay Kamath Bids Farewell to BusinessLine After 27 Years

April 30, 2025
0

Chennai: After nearly four decades in journalism and 27 illustrious years at The Hindu BusinessLine, Vinay Kamath, Senior Associate Editor,...

AUTHOR'S CORNER

Bricks, Clicks & Billboards: Redefining Real Estate Marketing for the New-Age Buyer
Authors Corner

Bricks, Clicks & Billboards: Redefining Real Estate Marketing for the New-Age Buyer

May 10, 2025
0

The real estate industry today stands at a fascinating crossroads. It is no longer just about concrete structures, architectural brilliance,...

UPLIFT MEDIANEWS4U DIGITAL PVT LTD
No. 194B , Aram Nagar 2, JP Road,
Versova, Andheri West
Mumbai - 400061

For editorial queries:
[email protected]
[email protected]

For business queries:
Smitha Sapaliga - +91-98337-15455
[email protected]

Recent News

The future of marketing relies on blending hyper-personalisation, immersive experiences, and predictive intelligence: Swati Bhargava, CashKaro

The future of marketing relies on blending hyper-personalisation, immersive experiences, and predictive intelligence: Swati Bhargava, CashKaro

May 13, 2025
Abhishek Mehrotra Quits News24, joins AATHARVI Production Multimedia as President

Abhishek Mehrotra Quits News24, joins AATHARVI Production Multimedia as President

May 13, 2025
CNN elevates Ellana Lee to Global senior role, expands focus on Sponsored Content

CNN elevates Ellana Lee to Global senior role, expands focus on Sponsored Content

May 12, 2025

Newsletter

Subscribe to Newsletters

Medianews4u.com © 2019 - 2024 All rights reserved.

  • The South Side Story 2023 Download Report
  • Goafest 2023: Day 3
  • Goafest 2023: Day 2
  • Goafest 2023: Day 1
  • Straight Talk Gallery 2022
  • The South Side Story 2022 Download Report
  • Focus 2022
  • Futurescope Conclave Gallery 2022
  • The South Side Story 2021 Download Report
  • FOCUS 2021
  • Exclusive
  • Exclusive
  • Advertising
  • Media
    • Radio
    • Cable & DTH
    • Print
    • Digital Frontier
    • Gaming Nexus
  • Television
  • OTT
  • Ad-Tech
  • Marketing
  • Campaigns
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Think Through
    • Prescience 2023
    • Prescience 2024
  • People
  • Events
    • Leader Speak
    • STRAIGHT TALK
    • Gamechangers
    • Print & TV Summit

Medianews4u.com © 2019 - 2024 All rights reserved.