• Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • Prescience 2023
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • Goafest 2022
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • Think Through
Saturday, February 4, 2023
MediaNews4U
  • Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • Prescience 2023
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • Goafest 2022
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
        • Market Analysis
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • Think Through
No Result
View All Result
MediaNews4U
  • Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • Prescience 2023
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • Goafest 2022
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
        • Market Analysis
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • Think Through
No Result
View All Result
MediaNews4U.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Advertising

Nigeria bans non-Nigerian models: Will Indian ads drop ‘aspirational’ white skin? Part 2

Ban not the answer, concur Ambi Parameswaran, Raj Kamble, Ramesh Narayan and Sharad Haksar; ‘Un-stereotyping is the new aspiration,’ says Rohit Ohri.

by Editorial
September 5, 2022
in Advertising, Exclusive, Featured
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
Nigeria bans non-Nigerian models: Will Indian ads drop ‘aspirational’ white skin? Part 2
Share Share ShareShare

Nigeria announced a ban – effective 1 October 2022 – on non-Nigerian models and VO artistes in advertising on Nigerian media. This space was said to be dominated by white and British talent. The Advertising Regulatory Council of Nigeria has welcomed the move. 

The move is ostensibly to encourage local talent. It is also perhaps an indication that white models are no longer aspirational and in no less measure of local pride.

Ad veteran and Founder of Canco Advertising Ramesh Narayan hopes that such a ban is never witnessed in India. 

“It would be a sad day if anyone is banned from being used in Indian advertising. Indian society has always been pluralistic, accepting and tolerant. Also, the choice of the model should be dictated by the personality of the brand, the needs of the market and the creative interpretation of these two factors. Nothing else should come in the way of advertising. 

“Communication should not fall between jingoistic lines. It can and should be used for healthy commercial expression that benefits the owner of the brand and presents the power of choice to the audience,” notes Narayan. 

Ambi Parameswaran, Founder, Brand- Building.com, adds that measures like banning models will only create new ways of circumvention.

He explains, “Each country does its bit to encourage local talent. I remember Pakistan had once laid down a rule that people with Indian passports cannot model for any of their advertising and that ads cannot be made in India. This did not help their local industry in any way. I am not a fan of Caucasian models who appear in ads for apparel, liquor (surrogate), and other product ads. But banning them is not the right response. It will create an unnecessary hurdle and clever new ways of circumvention.” 

Rather than a defensive approach, India’s outlook needs to be positive, is his take. He adds, “Our ad industry is large and vibrant. Our models have gone on to become global stars (Priyanka Chopra is the latest)! We should as a country be proud of what our films and music are doing for our country and encourage their widespread dissemination. If South Korea is made famous through K-Pop and K-Serials why not India. We have so much to offer to the world.”

Raj Kamble, Founder and CCO, Famous Innovations, views the development from  a creator’s perspective. 

Says Kamble, “Whenever s/he thinks of an idea, a creative person wants the resources and the talent most appropriate to bring that idea to life to the fullest extent possible. That talent may be regional, national or international, be it models, directors, photographers, voice artistes, musicians or whatever it may be. If available locally, we will obviously choose the locally available talent. But to say we should ban foreign talent is a curb on creativity.”

“The talent best suited for the job should be used. That choice should be left to the creators,” he adds.

Rohit Ohri, Chairman & CEO, FCB Group India, reminds us of the current Indian reality. 

“’Aspirational fair skin’… what is that? For Gen Z, being yourself and happy in your skin is what matters. This is, fortunately, true for Bharat and not just India. To connect with this generation, brands need to take a progressive stance. The real need is to be seen as embracing inclusion and diversity and not standing for regressive beliefs of the past. Un-stereotyping is the new aspiration,” he substantiates.  

Every few years, news articles have pointed to India’s obsession with foreign models from automobiles to accessories. While the number seems to have vastly reduced, there is still a prevalence, whether ostensibly to underline a brand’s pedigree or create an international aura. There are also bizarre cases like Pierce Brosnan endorsing Pan Bahar.

Photographer Sharad Haksar, Founder of creative shop 1pointsize and OneEyeLand.com, concurs that things are changing for the better. 

Says Haksar, “Sensibilities and preferences are changing. Look at the acceptance of South Indian movies across India. The most successful movies and shows are not necessarily the ones with big names or banners, or those in Hindi or English. They appeal to the sensibilities of India, with substance. The shift is certainly there and it will reflect in advertising too, but a ban is not the answer. Often, a ban tends to have the opposite effect to what is desired.”

He surmises, “India looked up to foreign products and that got carried into the advertising. The day we have products that you want to take with you whenever you travel abroad, it will also reflect in the advertising. We are so up there when it comes to products like food, but there is a need for R&D and product development in many other categories.”

Articulating the move by Nigeria as one driven by national pride, Josy Paul – Chairman and Chief Creative Officer of BBDO India said, “From what I understand, Nigeria’s Federal Ministry of Information and Culture are banning the use of all foreign models and voice-over artists on Nigerian media to create greater opportunity for local talent. There could be a larger Nigerian national pride at play here. When it comes to India, we’ve been using Indian cast in all our ads. There’s been no requests for foreign models in our campaigns these days. Indians are the new aspirational models for Indians.”

Reiterating the need for relatability and authenticity he added, “Still, the idea of localizing your ad goes beyond just casting for nationality and physical appearance. You need people who can connect with your target audience on a more personal level be it interests, values, and behaviour. It’s all about relatability and authenticity. A misrepresented ad can not only cost brands money, but could also alienate existing customers.”

(Part 2/2. Have a view? Write to Ediorial@medianews4u.com.)

Also read: Nigeria bans non-Nigerian models: Good or bad? Will Indian ads drop ‘aspirational’ white skin? Part 1

Tags: Advertising Regulatory Council of NigeriaAmbi ParameswaranBBDO IndiaFamous InnovationsFCB Group IndiaInternationalJosy PaulNigeriaRaj KambleRamesh NarayanRohit OhriSharad Haksar

Related Posts

SIXAM Glow launches in India with its #HalfTheNewDouble Campaign
Brand Stories

SIXAM Glow launches in India with #HalfTheNewDouble campaign

February 3, 2023
AJIO launches Sneakerhood 2.0 campaign conceptualized by Phantom Ideas
Brand Stories

AJIO launches Sneakerhood 2.0 campaign conceptualised by Phantom Ideas

February 3, 2023

LATEST NEWS

AJIO launches Sneakerhood 2.0 campaign conceptualized by Phantom Ideas

AJIO launches Sneakerhood 2.0 campaign conceptualised by Phantom Ideas

February 3, 2023
SBI Life’s campaign appeals to the ‘responsible ambition’ fuelling consumers

SBI Life’s campaign appeals to the ‘responsible ambition’ fuelling consumers

February 3, 2023

MARKET ANALYSIS

Ad volumes soar by 29pc on TV GEC genre in 2022 over 2018: TAM Report
Featured

Digital ad spend in India to surpass TV in 2023: Report

by Editorial
February 2, 2023
0

According to Dentsu's India Digital Report 2023, the Indian advertising industry is expected to grow at a rate of 15.07% and...

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Nona Lifestyle onboards Ketan Jansari as Vice President
Featured

Nona Lifestyle onboards Ketan Jansari as Vice President

by Editorial
February 3, 2023
0

Nona Lifestyle has announced the appointment of Ketan Jansari as the Vice President of their managed marketplace. With a mercantile...

Bonn Group appoints Dawinder Pal as Business Head for House of Veda and Group Marketing Head

Bonn Group appoints Dawinder Pal as Business Head for House of Veda and Group Marketing Head

February 3, 2023

MARKETING

UK’s Barry M forays into Indian Market in association with Myntra
Featured

UK’s Barry M forays into Indian Market in association with Myntra

by Editorial
February 3, 2023
0

Barry M, the UK's color cosmetics brand, has entered India through its partnership with Myntra and Progressive Lifestyles. The brand...

Subscribe to Newsletters

ADVERTISING

Aqilliz and Affine announce strategic partnership
Advertising

Aqilliz and Affine announce strategic partnership

by Editorial
February 2, 2023
0

Aqilliz, a digital marketing middleware technology company, has partnered with Affine, an AI services firm, to develop a federated learning...

Ogilvy Indonesia appoints Satish Ramanathan as MD

Ogilvy Indonesia appoints Satish Ramanathan as MD

February 2, 2023
D2C brands and influencer non-disclosures push personal care to Top 3 violative sectors: Report

D2C brands and influencer non-disclosures push personal care to Top 3 violative sectors: Report

February 2, 2023

PRINT

THG wins 4 awards at WAN-IFRA South Asian Digital Media Awards 2022
Featured

THG wins 4 awards at WAN-IFRA South Asian Digital Media Awards 2022

by Editorial
February 2, 2023
0

The Hindu Group bagged four awards at the WAN-IFRA Digital Media South Asia Awards 2022. TH Newsletters won silver in...

Forbes India unveils winners of 30 Under 30 2023

Forbes India unveils winners of 30 Under 30 2023

January 31, 2023
Network18 undertakes advertising blitzkrieg to announce launch of Palki Sharma’s new show

Network18 undertakes advertising blitzkrieg to announce launch of Palki Sharma’s new show

January 26, 2023

MY COLUMN

Salaam Malayalam
Featured

24 frames of Gender Emancipation: Anup Chandrasekharan

by Editorial
January 31, 2023
0

The effervescence of feminine quotient in films was little too high in the 80’s and then by itself deteriorated and...

Contact Us :

UPLIFT MEDIANEWS4U DIGITAL PVT LTD

No. 194B , Aram Nagar 2, JP Road

Versova, Andheri West

Mumbai - 400061

Umanath.V
+91-99400-17868
umanath@medianews4u.com

© 2019 medianews4u.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Media
    • Exclusive
    • Buzz
    • Movers & Shakers
    • Events
    • International
  • Prescience 2023
  • Television
  • Advertising
    • Goafest 2022
    • PR
    • Mobile/Digital
      • Marketing
  • Radio
  • OTT
  • Print
  • Cable & DTH
  • Brand Stories
  • Leaderspeak
  • STRAIGHT TALK
  • Think Through

Medianews4u.com © 2019 - 2022 All rights reserved.