Saturday, July 12, 2025
MediaNews4U
  • Exclusive
  • Advertising
  • Media
    • Radio
    • Cable & DTH
    • Print
    • Digital Frontier
    • Gaming Nexus
  • Television
  • OTT
  • Ad-Tech
  • Marketing
  • Campaigns
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Think Through
    • Prescience 2023
    • Prescience 2024
  • People
  • Events
    • Leader Speak
    • STRAIGHT TALK
    • Gamechangers
    • Print & TV Summit
MediaNews4U
  • Exclusive
  • Advertising
  • Media
    • Radio
    • Cable & DTH
    • Print
    • Digital Frontier
    • Gaming Nexus
  • Television
  • OTT
  • Ad-Tech
  • Marketing
  • Campaigns
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Think Through
    • Prescience 2023
    • Prescience 2024
  • People
  • Events
    • Leader Speak
    • STRAIGHT TALK
    • Gamechangers
    • Print & TV Summit
MediaNews4U.com
Home Featured

Opinion: To award, or not to award?

Fresh off chairing a jury at the One Show Abby, the author enlists some of the guiding principles he has picked up in a decade of judging awards and many more years of entering them.

by Sabyasachi Mitter
May 29, 2023
in Featured, Exclusive, Opinion
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
Circa 2024: Things are going to get really crazy with Gen AI
Share Share ShareShare

Being on the jury of any award is a tough job. Not because judging work is a difficult job per se. But because being on the jury means one has to remove oneself from one’s beliefs, biases and prejudices, which often jury members find hard to do. Having judged work at numerous award shows over the last 10 years, here are some of my guiding principles, which I also share with fellow jurors whenever I have had the opportunity to be a Jury Chair.

ADVERTISEMENT

We have come a long way in terms of improving processes followed and ensuring the rigour of judging. We even have auditors today to document and ensure due process. And yes, they are all welcome. Yet, like Generative AI that is all the rage, it is the basic inputs that impact outcomes, not the systems themselves.

For the duration of the judging, we need to only rely on our skills and assessment and never let personal opinion, likes or dislikes come in the way of judging. Easier said than done, but I have seen this to be one of the main issues many new jury members face.

We need to judge the work dispassionately and not the context or whether you believe it was right or wrong.

Category & Context

When we judge a piece of work in a category, we need to think in the context of the category and that needs to be paramount. We may often fall in love with a piece of work, but before assessing, we need to be clear in our head about the guardrails and constraints of the category within which we need to evaluate it. The same campaign entered in 10 categories may win Gold in one but not even garner a merit in another – that’s because the jury views the breakthrough claimed or achieved in the category context.

Every award has a purpose and stands for something. A clear understanding of the award show’s goals and objectives helps. A creative award is about the idea and execution, not the scale and results, whereas an effectiveness award is about the tangible results delivered and not necessarily how creative the work is. Depending on what we are judging, we need to change our judging hats. In the present reality, creative work wins effectiveness and technology awards, and you have categories like creative use of media / tech platforms. It can get a little overwhelming if we don’t stay true to the award’s reason for existence.

Speak Up

Some jury members tend to be more forthright, and I dare say even forceful, than others. Every jury member must speak his or her mind for the jury to collectively do its job right. Never be afraid to go against the general mood of fellow jurors when you have a strong, unbiased point of view. Jury members are humans and can get carried away but if there is something fundamentally amiss, one needs to dispassionately reason it out without making it an ego battle. A jury chair’s job can seem thankless in some situations, but if every view is heard and informs the jury’s decision, you can be satisfied with a job well done.

Spotting an entry that may not be authentic is no less a critical need and a jury member must be able to logically reason whether the piece of work is infeasible to start with. This especially applies to digital and technology where some claims look infeasible beyond doubt. Across categories, if there are murmurs of a piece of work that should oh-so-obviously not have gone up on the winner table, please take a look at who judged them. But don’t judge the ones who judged yet – we’re getting there.

The last one is a perennial point of discussion, because agencies that spend a lot of money entering awards have realised over the years that they also need to invest in the presentation. There is nothing wrong with that. But the jury needs to be able to look beyond the surface. We need to look at the substance and not the presentation of the submission. Too often, a dazzling case study presentation AV sways the jury. I do believe an entrant must make a proper AV presentation of the work. As a jury we need to sift through what’s being shown and arrive at the core of that piece of work before judging.

I am writing this from Goafest where I had the privilege of being a Jury Chair, but these are learnings from all awards I have judged over the years. Across shows, the choice of jury, transparency in its working and clarity of what one is judging makes a huge difference to the stature of the award. We get better as jurors, one award show at a time.

Here’s to another successful edition of the Abbys at Goafest. I look forward to many more, where the most deserving work wins.

(The author is Founder and MD, ibs Fulcro and served as the Jury Chair of the Technology Abby at the Abby One Show at Goafest 2023.)

(First published by The Free Press Journal BrandSutra. Content powered by MediaNews4u.com. Feedback: [email protected])

Tags: AIGoafestGoafest 2023One Show AbbyOpinionSabyasachi Mitter

RECENT POSTS

At Sony Music Publishing India, we safeguard songwriters' rights with copyright management and fair royalty collection: Dinraj Shetty
Exclusive

At Sony Music Publishing India, we safeguard songwriters’ rights with copyright management and fair royalty collection: Dinraj Shetty

July 11, 2025
0

As the global music community comes together to celebrate World Music Day on 21 June, we often focus on the...

Read more
Brand advocacy involves stakeholders sharing content and views on brands and categories: Ajit Narayan, Socxo
Exclusive

Brand advocacy involves stakeholders sharing content and views on brands and categories: Ajit Narayan, Socxo

July 10, 2025
0

There is a growing trend of B2B influencers and employee generated content. Platforms like Linkedin and even Instagram are now...

Read more
Being research-driven means we ask a lot of questions: Shriya Seshadri, SummerOwl Studio
Exclusive

Being research-driven means we ask a lot of questions: Shriya Seshadri, Summer Owl Studio

July 9, 2025
0

Summer Owl Studio started with a simple intention, to create innovative designs that are thought-out and intentionally produced, and to...

Read more
Before anything, products have to deliver on the style statement. That’s key: Rohit Trivedi
Exclusive

Before anything, products have to deliver on the style statement. That’s key: Rohit Trivedi, Zeel Climate Clothing

July 8, 2025
0

As the rains begin to pour across the country, Zeel Climate Clothing, a rainwear brand, is looking to make a...

Read more
In recent years, IPRS has experienced significant and diverse membership growth: Rakesh Nigam
Exclusive

In recent years, IPRS has experienced significant and diverse membership growth: Rakesh Nigam

July 7, 2025
0

This World Music Day 21 June, The Indian Performing Right Society Ltd. (IPRS) is amplifying the conversation around creator rights,...

Read more
Seeding the Future: How Mandeep and Karan are Turning IAMGAME into India’s Sports Catalyst
Exclusive

Seeding the Future: How Mandeep and Karan are Turning IAMGAME into India’s Sports Catalyst

July 7, 2025
0

India’s sports economy is on the cusp of explosive growth, with projections placing its value at $100 billion by 2027....

Read more

LATEST NEWS

A Tale of Two Finals: How India’s Absence Impacted Ad Volumes in ICC Test Championship 2025

A Tale of Two Finals: How India’s Absence Impacted Ad Volumes in ICC Test Championship 2025

July 12, 2025
Green Trends launches ‘Big Style’s Extra’ with exciting salon rewards all July

Green Trends launches ‘Big Style’s Extra’ with exciting salon rewards all July

July 12, 2025

ANALYSIS

A Tale of Two Finals: How India’s Absence Impacted Ad Volumes in ICC Test Championship 2025
Analysis

A Tale of Two Finals: How India’s Absence Impacted Ad Volumes in ICC Test Championship 2025

July 12, 2025
0

The ICC Test Championship Final is not just a battle for the crown of cricket’s purest format — it’s also...

PEOPLE

Sarina Menezes elevated to SVP & Head – Marketing & Corporate Communication at Oberoi Realty
People

Sarina Menezes elevated to SVP & Head – Marketing & Corporate Communication at Oberoi Realty

July 12, 2025
0

Mumbai: Oberoi Realty Ltd., has promoted Sarina Menezes to Senior Vice President & Head – Marketing & Corporate Communication. Prior...

MARKETING

Lola Cars and Warner Bros. Discovery Forge Multi-Year Partnership with Electrifying Superman Livery for Berlin E-Prix
Marketing

Lola Cars and Warner Bros. Discovery Forge Multi-Year Partnership with Electrifying Superman Livery for Berlin E-Prix

July 12, 2025
0

Mumbai: Motorsport innovation meets superhero spectacle as Lola Cars and Warner Bros. Discovery announce a dynamic multi-year partnership that combines...

Subscribe to Newsletters

ADVERTISING

GreenHonchos wins Digital Growth Mandate from Premium Menswear Brand Blackberrys
Advertising

GreenHonchos wins Digital Growth Mandate from Premium Menswear Brand Blackberrys

July 11, 2025
0

Mumbai: Blackberrys Fashion, a menswear brand, has announced a strategic partnership with GreenHonchos, India’s top digital commerce enabler, to bolster...

PRINT

Vikatan Group MD B Srinivasan to Speak at FIPP World Media Congress on Deepening Audience Connections
Media

Vikatan Group MD B Srinivasan to Speak at FIPP World Media Congress on Deepening Audience Connections

June 27, 2025
0

Chennai: As Indian media house Vikatan Group approaches its centenary, Managing Director B Srinivasan is set to speak at the...

AUTHOR'S CORNER

Ganapathy Viswanathan
Authors Corner

Why PR Is the Secret Weapon Behind a Strong Personal Brand

July 11, 2025
0

In today’s fast-moving digital world, your personal brand isn’t just a “nice to have” — it’s your reputation. Whether you're...

UPLIFT MEDIANEWS4U DIGITAL PVT LTD
No. 194B , Aram Nagar 2, JP Road,
Versova, Andheri West
Mumbai - 400061

For editorial queries:
[email protected]
[email protected]

For business queries:
Smitha Sapaliga - +91-98337-15455
[email protected]

Recent News

Lola Cars and Warner Bros. Discovery Forge Multi-Year Partnership with Electrifying Superman Livery for Berlin E-Prix

Lola Cars and Warner Bros. Discovery Forge Multi-Year Partnership with Electrifying Superman Livery for Berlin E-Prix

July 12, 2025
A Tale of Two Finals: How India’s Absence Impacted Ad Volumes in ICC Test Championship 2025

A Tale of Two Finals: How India’s Absence Impacted Ad Volumes in ICC Test Championship 2025

July 12, 2025
Green Trends launches ‘Big Style’s Extra’ with exciting salon rewards all July

Green Trends launches ‘Big Style’s Extra’ with exciting salon rewards all July

July 12, 2025

Newsletter

Subscribe to Newsletters

Medianews4u.com © 2019 - 2024 All rights reserved.

  • The South Side Story 2023 Download Report
  • Goafest 2023: Day 3
  • Goafest 2023: Day 2
  • Goafest 2023: Day 1
  • Straight Talk Gallery 2022
  • The South Side Story 2022 Download Report
  • Focus 2022
  • Futurescope Conclave Gallery 2022
  • The South Side Story 2021 Download Report
  • FOCUS 2021
  • Exclusive
  • Exclusive
  • Advertising
  • Media
    • Radio
    • Cable & DTH
    • Print
    • Digital Frontier
    • Gaming Nexus
  • Television
  • OTT
  • Ad-Tech
  • Marketing
  • Campaigns
  • Analysis
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Think Through
    • Prescience 2023
    • Prescience 2024
  • People
  • Events
    • Leader Speak
    • STRAIGHT TALK
    • Gamechangers
    • Print & TV Summit

Medianews4u.com © 2019 - 2024 All rights reserved.